As a child, Skylar Mackenzie’s imagination always got her in trouble. Now it’s making her a fortune. She owns Imagine That, a toy and book store and creativity center in a small Rhode Island beach town where children can use their imagination free from judgment. It has quickly expanded into a second space, Imagine That Too, for creative and de-stressing programs for adults, popular with parents and corporate execs.
Just as Skye is about to embark on retreat in town for the local businesses, she's shocked to discover her half-sister Amy, who has been gone for almost fifteen years, on the doorstep of her Aunt Roxy's B&B. And she's not alone.
Always the pretty, well-behaved one to Skye's wild child, Amy's insatiable need for more ended up hurting everyone, including Skye, and when she blew out of town, she was joined by Skye's first love, Conner Reid. Skye turned to her beloved Aunt Roxy and promised she wouldn't let Amy hurt her ever again.
Now Amy's back, she swears she wants to make it up to Skye, but soon she's up to her old tricks and wreaking havoc all throughout the town. Connor tries to convince her to leave, and himself that he no longer has feelings for Skye, but to no avail.
When a devastating fire spreads through the retreat, just a week before the start date, Skye is terrified that history is repeating itself, that Amy has started the fire in a misplaced act of revenge. Amy is innocent, but when she sees how her actions have hurt her sister, she knows she needs to change her life.
As the town bands together to rebuild the retreat, Amy and Skye realize in order to rebuild their relationship and move on, they must face the past. History doesn’t always have to repeat itself, not if you’re willing to fight for what you love and accept a little help from your friends.